THIS IS ALREADY THE HEIGHT OF THE MANIPULATION THEY DON'T COUNT US THEIR PROBLEM

Answer to the Article facilitated by Xavier Sedó, member of the editorial advice of, The Economist in Catalonia. 

They are already desires on one hand of writing economic foolishness and for another desires of to take charge them that are written I believe that the illustrious economist that has signed this I articulate that I will rebut they will have paid him to make it if it is that will do everybody he is entitled to be earned a living, if it is not this way and he has written it because it is their real way to see the economy, sad favor is done and I eat not here he has me to contradict me if he wants to maintain it.  

I don't want to enter a lot in the political part with which it introduces the topic because I believe that in that he still goes but lost that in the economy undoubtedly not alone the Catalan and all Spain vote the constitution already 35 years ago and that it is maybe that for you and others that think a sentence of irrevocable death that is the one equally in route to that that action us eta taking,  

This Constitution just as he says in their writing it doesn't contemplate a parceled sovereignty neither the right to decide the self-determination of a region unilaterally because it proclaims that the sovereignty relapses in the entirety of the Spanish town. But neither it contemplates 27 % unemployment with more than 7, 5 million people affected in more or less measure, neither it contemplates the attack of the conscience and the education, Catalan, neither the ribbon and it loosens on the abortion, neither the flight of companies of young neither it contemplates the presumed salvaged of robberies, embezzlements and grafts of political to the government's front and governments banks and savings banks, among other things.  

It is not certain that the Catalan politicians Generalitat or Parlament have not outlined modification undoubtedly some in a formal way they have proposed it as much in Madrid as in the parliament but another thing is that he wants to get lost the time in it because he will know you that neither the PP neither the PSOE want a single point of this constitution that one has come to be to move but rigid that the last dictatorship. He says you that he would suit to remember this fundamental fact in the argument and debates on the part of those that don't accept the independent and less still like he is thinking about this it is in fact what they are making hide and to be protected after the constitution. 

I don't want neither to comment the national feeling that redounds in your comment that it is the citizens' the obligation to accept the Constitution and of the State to make it complete democratically through their Institutions and Authorities elects. And the Government of the Nation assumes this command, as it could not be otherwise. The own Constitution establishes the procedure to continue for its reformation, but the secessionists of CDC and ERC they don't contemplate this road for its aspirations and if they make it PSOE and PSC proposing a model federalist. This is it that before told him this is not to apply the constitution with freedom and accommodation this is to throw you the constitution to the head and if it is not enough and it doesn't kill you they already sent you the army if he decides. 

I don't know from where it takes out you that: - It seems clear that most of the Catalan town is totally misinformed on what would be the independent Catalonia, because nobody proposes him this reflection. In their place, you appeals to the national feelings, to glean victim in a history falsified, to improvised declarations and not very solvent and to promote festival manifestations that demonstrate the political will of deviating the attention on the terrible autonomous administration attributing it to other people's guilt’s, with the lure of an independence that is not explained with seriousness. And, unfortunately, it also demonstrates the popular immaturity that you points blindly to any to flame of flags that it is not that of Spain. You don't have neither he devises of the social movements that move in Catalonia in towns city councils entities etc. where it is explained that we want and that we would get with our independence. 

Nevertheless if you want to criticize us for lack of information because you don't criticize same and to their dear Spain that doesn't explain to their society that if Catalonia leaves Spain it can be so unbalanced economically that the risk runs of falling to unsuspected limits of poverty because he doesn't explain to them that today they maintain Spain Madrid and Catalonia and that if it fails a, it is 50% what really gets lost for that reason here if he has space its comments - Those that quietly they don't participate of this secessionist fervor neither of gratuitous euphoria’s questions are asked that at the moment nobody outlines and, therefore, nobody answers - but it doesn't direct them to us to the Catalan but to the Spaniards that don't have neither he devises of what you are played.  

And you ask: What treatment would an independent Catalonia give the Catalan that wanted to continue being Spanish, maintaining its residence in Catalonia? Because the same one of which enjoys any European foreigner that lives their children studies he goes to the hospital it charges their salary and he leaves vacations to their town every year, as for of rights and duties, to physicality for that he shows off that it would be very high, and to the Social security, if it was transferred him. Of who and what guarantees they would aid the medical and social benefits and the collection of their pensions 

The question is not unconscious and does he come to story for the very precarious financial situation of Catalonia whose current public debt overcome the 50.000 millions of and ascending, with a qualification of Voucher garbage, which suggests expectations of high types of interest on the part of the markets, if they lent us that would already see. At the moment, it is easier and cheaper to appeal Spain that is already the main worthy of the Catalan debt (34%). Exact at the moment but because it doesn't continue for the logical road of the figures you point next. 

But it is that, also, in a supposition independent Catalan State, to the autonomous current debt he would be necessary to add the aliquot part that would correspond him of the Spanish public debt in the moment of the separation - at the moment it already fences of the 900.000 millions of and that some experts calculate between 100 or 110 thousand additional millions. In total, the debt public initial for the independent Catalonia is considered that it could be very well of the order of the 150/160.000 million Eurus I see that if he knows how to see the numbers I agree on them but friend you don't interpret them well you will do a new Catalonia with a debt of 160.000 million Eurus and a GDP of 190.000 (I am pessimistic) it is that he has a smaller debt percentage that the remaining Spain you make numbers  

Catalonia would spread a debt that would mean 81.2%. Spain its Spain would have a debt of 1, 000,000 less millions the 160,000 that Catalonia would assume, 840.000 million Eurus what would mean that with a GDP of 980,000 less millions the 190,000 millions that he would no longer receive from Catalonia would go down the GDP to 790,000 but let us leave them in 800,000 so that this is not said he gives that the Spain would be a country with an equivalent sovereign debt to 100% of the GDP so who serious but garbage  

There is not any fear of the reflexive Catalan to see committed their future, their work positions, their investments, their savings, he even can that their bank balances are in europa and in the century 21 thing that you seem to forget, and of course we are clever to support a fiscal pressure that would be no bigger than the current one and to have some managerial expectations of great uncertainty, it seems quite justified to think that there would be some of good and others of bad you don't doubt it. 

Until here I arrive, I don't want to enter in considerations of the UE neither of the BCE in those that you extend very apocalyptically but for the same thing that you refer that they have not been pronounced in anything concrete I tell to you that with the numbers in the hand and being Catalonia net taxpayer to the funds of the UE would not leave us outside a lot of time the just to for the paper work and regarding euro this but that known that you could work with him. Anything but alone to wish us to all independent and not a happy one and I prosper year 2014, and don't worry but please don't say more lies neither scare the children more.